Sunday, October 5, 2008

Citigroup Goes to Court Over Wachovia

Bloomberg is reporting that Citigroup, who is in a takeover battle with Wells Fargo over control of Wachovia, filed a petition and a New York state court judge granted an order extending the bank's "exclusivity agreement" with Wachovia after Wells Fargo announced a competing bid on Friday.  New York State Supreme Court Judge Charles Ramos issued the emergency injunction  late Saturday night, extending Citigroup's agreement to negotiate the acquisition of parts of Charlotte-based Wachovia "until further order of the court," Citigroup said in an e- mailed statement.

Citigroup fell as much as 21% Friday after Wells Fargo, the biggest U.S. bank on the West Coast, agreed to acquire all of Wachovia for $15.1 billion. The bid trumped Citigroup's government-backed offer of $2.16 billion for Wachovia's banking operations.

"The taxpayer doesn't pay a penny" for the Wells Fargo deal, Wells Chairman Richard Kovacevich, 64, said Friday in an interview. His company's bid is superior to Citigroup's also because it's a higher price and the combining banks "share similar cultures and values."

Vikram Pandit, Citigroup's chief executive officer, is counting on the Wachovia purchase to help rebuild after three quarters of losses totaling more than $17 billion. The bank's market value has dropped 38% this year to about $100 billion, leaving it below Wells Fargo. If Wells Fargo winds up with Wachovia, it would creep up on its New York rival with deposits of $787 billion, compared with Citigroup's $826 billion.

Citi's Claim

Pandit insisted Citigroup will prevail, citing the exclusive agreement signed by Wachovia. Kovacevich told investors during a conference call the deal with Wachovia is "solid."

Citigroup finished 18% lower to $18.35 on Friday after having its biggest share decline in about 20 years. Wachovia rose 59% to $6.21. Wells Fargo declined 1.7% to $34.56.

Citigroup demanded Wells Fargo abandon the takeover. Buying Wachovia would give Citigroup the third-biggest U.S. bank network and cement its status as the nation's largest lender by assets.

"Any such agreement between Wachovia and Wells Fargo is illegal," Pandit, 51, said in the e-mail Friday. "We continue to vigorously pursue Citigroup's interest and rights in completing this transaction."

Citigroup may increase its offer, said a person with knowledge of the deliberations.


"I'm still not convinced that Citigroup can force this sale to happen," said Elizabeth Nowicki, a professor at Tulane University Law School in New Orleans. "Citigroup may be facing the chance to get themselves a small settlement, and that's a nice shot in the arm for a company that's struggling."

A court challenge and a bidding war aren't the only possible roadblocks for Wells Fargo: Its offer may lead to a face-off with federal regulators.

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC), helped broker Citigroup's purchase when Wachovia's health faltered. Chairman Sheila Bair said until a review of Wells Fargo's offer is completed, the agency will stand behind the Citigroup deal.

"We wanted to make clear that until things are settled with what's going on with this Wells bid, that the Citi deal was still there," Bair said Friday in an interview. Bair said the FDIC is reviewing the offer, and she said You should not assume the U.S. opposes Wells's offer.

Wells Fargo's Plan

Other bank regulators said they haven't evaluated Wells Fargo's offer.

"We have not yet reviewed the new Wells Fargo proposal and the issues that it raises," the Federal Reserve and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency said Friday in a statement. "The regulators will be working with the parties to achieve an outcome that protects all Wachovia creditors, including depositors, insured and uninsured, and promotes market stability."

Wells Fargo, run by Chief Executive Officer John Stumpf, had avoided bets on the subprime-mortgage market that contributed to $588 billion in writedowns and credit losses for financial firms worldwide. Wachovia in 2006 purchased Golden West Financial for $24 billion, acquiring a portfolio of option-adjustable rate mortgages that helped lead to $9.6 billion in losses this year.

Wells Fargo, in bidding for Wachovia, deviates from a strategy of seeking smaller acquisitions with less risk to fill gaps in its branch network. After the combination, the bank would have $1.42 trillion in assets, which may rank third in the U.S. depending on what other bank mergers are completed. It would have 10,761 branches in 39 states.

Sources: Bloomberg, Reuters

No comments: